Monday, July 28, 2008

Howard Rich Primary Recap

Vouchers are not an end in themselves; they are a means to make a transition from a government to a market system … I sense that we are on the verge of a breakthrough in one state or another, which will then sweep like a wildfire through the rest of the country… ”

- Milton Friedman, Public Schools: Make Them Private (1995)

So just how badly does NYC millionaire Howard Rich want our state to be a "foothold state" for the privatization of public schools? How badly does he want a state house that will pass his voucher and tax credit agenda?

Judge for yourself. Below is Gervais' list of contributions from Howard Rich and associates during the 2008 South Carolina primaries.

The full list. From Kit Spires to Thad Viers; from Scott Singer to Tommy Stringer; from Naim Salahudeen to Joey Millwood-een.

Here are the key numbers:

A total of 37 candidates got a total of over $579,000 through the fundling scheme. $419,000 of that came from at least thirty entities using an address at 73 Spring St., New York City.

Eleven of the candidates were incumbents. Twelve were candidates in open-seat races. Fourteen were challengers.

Rich used his contributions to try to replace seven GOP lawmakers and seven Democrat lawmakers. He succeeded in replacing two (both GOP).

Seven of the twelve open-seat candidates who took money from Rich prevailed.

Three of the eleven incumbents who took money from Rich were defeated. Another one dropped out of the race the day he got the money.

Thirteen candidates got more than half their campaign funds through this out-of-state funding scheme, with the highest percentage being 97%.

That's the big picture. Here's the complete list:

Ed Rumsey, House District 2 (lost)(65%)
$1,000 5/30/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 123 LaSalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 The Stonecreek Group [Kevin Spillane], Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/30/2008 Paul Jost 2640 Jockey's Neck Trl, Williamsburg, VA
$1,000 5/30/2008 Paul Farago P.O. Box 8907 Asheville, NC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Doug Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd, Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 5/30/2008 John Kirtley, 339 S. Plant Ave., Tampa, FL
$1,000 5/30/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 5/12/2008 Bradford Management, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/12/2008 LaSalle Associations, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/12/2008 Alan J. Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Avenue NYC

Trey Whitehurst, House District 3 (lost)
$1,000 6/12/2008 51 First Ave. LLC 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 470 W. 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 332 E. 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 6/12/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23 Fl. NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY, Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Alan Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave. NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 Stonecreeek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/26/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/25/2008 Paul Farago, P.O. Box 8907, Ashville, NC
$1,000 5/02/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 4/30/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC

Tommy Stringer, House District 18 (won)
$1,000 6/03/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring Street, Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring Street Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 188 Clarmont LLC, 73 Spring Street Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring Street Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 W Road 1, Moutain Home, AR
$1,000 5/27/2008 The Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/19/2008 Alan Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave. NYC
$1,000 5/07/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/07/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm 507 NYC

Daniel Hamilton, House District 20 (unopposed)
$1,000 6/01/2008 The Stonecreek Group, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd., Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/03/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/03/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/01/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Road, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 4/28/2008 Alan Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave. NYC

Bob Leach, House District 21 (lost)
$1,000 3/14/2008 332 E 11 LLC (73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC)
$1,000 3/14/2008 188 Claremont LLC (73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC)
$1,000 3/14/2008 Joseph D. Stilwell (26 Broadway 23rd Flr. NYC)
$1,000 3/14/2008 Yvonne Rich (211 West Road 1 Mtn Home, AR)
$1,000 3/14/2008 John Kirtley (339 S. Plant Ave. Tampa, FL)

Wendy Nanney, House District 22 (won)

$1,000 5/29/2008 834-14 Realty, 73 Spring St NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Rich and Rich, 73 Spring St NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Springs St Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Kevin [Sp]Illane, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd 191 Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/28/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 A Partnership, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 51 First Ave LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 470 W 166, 73 Spring St Rm. 406 NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY, 73 Spring St NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 123 LaSalle, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/26/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 5/12/2008 Alan Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave NYC
$1,000 2/26/2008 John Kirtley, 339 S Plant Ave. Tampa, FL
$1,000 2/13/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Fl NYC

Raymond Russell, House District 31 (lost)(76%)
$1,000 5/27/08 Springrich Limited Partnership, 73 Spring St., Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Silver & Silver Properties LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Rich Acquisitions LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste 507 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 332 E11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Bradford Mgmt of NY Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 188 Claremount LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 470 W. 166th LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Rich & Rich Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Howard Rich Sole Proprietor, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Joseph D. Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 5/27/08 Paul R. Farago, P.O. Box 890, Asheville, NC
$1,000 5/27/08 Douglas H. Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL

Ken Roach, House District 34 (lost)(69%)
$1,000 6/19/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 Rich and Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste 507 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring Street Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 Howard Rich, Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY Inc, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 470 W. 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 332 E. 11 LLC, 73 Spring Street Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 4220 Broadway Inc, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 Joseph Stilwell 26 Broadway 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 Douglas Levine 2760 N. Bay Road Miami, FL

Roger Nutt, House District 35 (lost)
$1,000 6/01/2008 Newrich, LLC, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 188 Claremont LLC 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 538-14 Realty LLC 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 4220 Broadway Inc. 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 332 E. 11, LLC, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 Bradford Management of NY, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 470 W. 166 LLC 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 51 First Avenue, LLC, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 Dayrich, LLC, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 6/01/2008 Bayrich, LLC, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane), Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/30/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd., Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 5/30/2008 Joseph D Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Alan J Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave. NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Paul R. Farago P.O. Box 8907, Ashville, NC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Douglas H Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 5/09/2008 123 Lasalle Assoc., 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/09/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. NYC

(i)Joe Mahaffey, House District 36 (dropped out of race 2/29/08)
$1,000 2/29/2008 322 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 2/29/2008 538-14 Realty, LLC, 73 Springs St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 2/29 2008 Joseph D Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23 Flr. NYC
$1,000 2/29/2008 John Kirtley, 339 S. Plant Ave. Tampa, FL

(i) Ralph Davenport, House District 37 (lost)
$1,000 5/19/2008 123 Lasalle, Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 188 Claremont, LLC, 73 Spring St, Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 4220 Broadway, LLC, Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 4220 Broadway, Inc., 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/12/2008 Joseph D. Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 5/05/2008 Paul Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC

Joey Millwood, House District 38 (won)(65%)
$1000 5/30/2008 Streetrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 408 NYC
$1000 5/30/2008 Stilrich LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1000 5/30/2008 West 14 & 18 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/30/2008 SpringRich Limited Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1000 5/30/2008 John Kirtley, 339 S. Plant Ave. Tampa, FL
$1000 5/30/2008 Douglas Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1000 5/24/2008 Paul Jost, 2640 Jockeys Neck Trail, Williamsburg, VA
$1000 5/24/2008 The StoneCreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA
$1000 5/24/2008 Paul Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1000 5/24/2008 Joseph Stillwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Floor NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd 1, Mtn Home, AR
$1000 5/24/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 123 LaSalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 51 First Ave LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Rich and Rich Associates, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Rich Acquisitions LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Spooner LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Silver and Silver Properties, 73 Spring St Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Secure Data LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Spring Incorporated, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Rich and Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1000 5/16/2008 Alan Pomerantz, 767 5th Ave. NYC
$1000 5/14/2008 Bradford Mgmt of New York Inc., 73 Spring St. NYC
$1000 5/12/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC

Annie McDaniel, House District 41 (lost)(85%)
$1,000 6/10/2008 538-14 Realty LLC 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 Springrich Limited Partnership, 73 Spring St Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 HR Sole Proprietor Streetrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 4220 Broadway Inc, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 Bradford Mgmt of New York Inc, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 Silver & Silver Properties, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 Rich Asquisitions LLC, 73 Spring St STE 507 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 New Rich LLC, 73 Spring St Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 New Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 Spooner, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 Rich & Rich LLC, 73 Spring St STE 507 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2008 Secure Data LLC, 73 Spring St. STE. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/10/2006 Rich & Rich Associates, 73 Spring St Rm. 408 NYC

Deborah Long, House District 45 (won)
$1,000 6/02/2008 188 Claremont LLC 73 Spring Street Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring Street Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 The Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA
$1,000 6/02/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Joseph D Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Road 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 6/02/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/18/2008 123 LaSalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/18/2008 Alan J. Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave., NYC

UPDATE: Kyle Boyd, House District 48 (lost)
$1,000 6/02/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Joseph D Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23 Floor NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Yvonne Rich, 211 West Rd 1, Mountain Home, AZ
$1,000 6/02/2008 John Kirtley 339 S Plant Ave, Tampa, FL
$1,000 6/02/2008 Rich Acquisitions LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Secure Data LLC, 73 Spring St Ste 507 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 The Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacremento, CA
$1,000 6/02/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Rich & Rich LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY Inc., 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Howard Rich Sole Proprietor Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Rich & Rich & Associates A Partnership, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 118 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 A Partnership 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Alan J Pomerantz, 767 5th Ave NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 Douglas Levine, 2760 N Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 5/22/2008 Spooner LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Silver & Silver Properties LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Silver & Silver Properties LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/12/2008 LaSalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 5/12/2008 LaSalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC

Ennis Bryant, House District 50 (lost) (74%)
$1,000 5/29/2008 Yvonne Rich, 311 West Rd 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 5/29/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Robert K Costello, 2135 Sherman Avenue, Evanston, IL
$1,000 5/29/2008 Joseph D Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd St. NYC

Naim Salahudeen, House District 54 (lost)(61%)
$1,000 6/03/2008 Asheboro Investors, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 A Partnership Limited, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 LaSalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/18/2008 Douglas H. Levine, 2760 N.Bay Road, Miami Beach, FL

Zina Manning, House District 55 (lost)(96%)
$1000 5/29/2008 Joseph D Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23 Floor NYC
$1000 5/29/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd. 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1000 5/29/2008 Kevin Spillane, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd, Sacramento, CA
$1000 5/29/2008 Paul Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1000 5/29/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/29/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/29/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 5/29/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC

Priscilla Robinson, House District 66 (lost)
$1,000 5/22/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Rich & Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Howard Rich, Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Bradford Management of NY Inc., 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/20/2008 Joseph D Stillwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 5/18/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd. 1, Mountain Home, AR

(i) Thad Viers, House District 68 (won)
$1,000 5/23/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 123 LaSalle Inc., 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 4220 Broadway Inc, 73 Spring St Rm 408, NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY Inc, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 123 LaSalle Associates, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/15/2008 Douglas Levine, 2760 N Bay Road Miami Beach, FL

Sheri Few, House District 79 (lost)(51%)
$1,000 6/11/2008 123 Lasalle Inc, 73 Spring St Room 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Douglas H. Levine 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami, FL
$1,000 6/11/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 Alan J. Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave. NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Silver & Silver Properties LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/22/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 4220 Broadway Inc, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 470 W 166 LLC 73 Spring St. Room 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/19/2008 Howard Rich, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408, NYC
$1,000 5/15/2008 Douglas H. Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami, FL
$1,000 5/10/2008 The Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/05/2008 Paul R. Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1,000 5/01/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Road 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 4/29/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 4/29/2008 123 Lasalle Inc, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 3/04/2008 188 Claremont LLC 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 3/04/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Springs St. Rm. 507, NYC
$1,000 3/04/2008 Bradford Mgmt, 73 Springs St. Rm 507, NYC
$1,000 2/28/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 2/28/2008 John Kirtley, 339 S Plant Ave., Tampa, FL

Scott Singer, House 81 (lost)(Mr. Singer returned all but $3,000 of the contributions from 73 Spring Street, NYC)
$1,000 6/30/2008 4220 Broadway Inc, 73 Spring Street, Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 Silver & Silver Properties LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St, Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY Inc, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St., Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 123 Lasalle Inc, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Road 1 Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 6/30/2008 Douglas H Levine, 2760 N. Bay Road, Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 6/30/2008 Paul R. Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1,000 6/30/2008 Joseph D Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 Alan J Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Avenue NYC
$1,000 6/30/2008 The Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA

James E. Whitehead, House District 83 (lost) (97%)
$1,000 6/03/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd. 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 6/03/2008 Joseph D. Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 Alan J Pomerantz, 666 Fifth Ave., 5th Floor NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St, Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 The Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA
$1,000 6/03/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY Inc., 73 Springs St. Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 6/03/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm 507 NYC

(i)Heyward Hutson, House District 94 (lost)

$1,000 6/02/2008 Paul R Farago, P.O. Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1,000 6/02/2008 The Stonecreek Group, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd, Sacramento, CA
$1,000 6/02/2008 Joseph D. Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23 Flr NYC
$1,000 5/16/2008 Alan J. Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave. NYC
$1,000 5/16/2008 123 Lasalle Associates A Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 5/16/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm 507 NYC
$1,000 5/16/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd 1, Mountain Home, AR

(i)Kit Spires, House District 96 (won)
$1,000 5/12/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway NYC
$1,000 5/26/2008 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC

Wendell Gilliard, House District 111 (won)
$1,000 6/11/2008 332 E 11 LLC A Partnership, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 123 Lasalle Associates A Partnership, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. NYC

Joseph Bustos, House District 112 (lost)(55%)
$1,000 6/02/2008 Rich Acquisitions, 73 Spring St. Ste 507 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Rich and Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Rich & Rich Assoc., 73 Spring St. Ste 507 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 Silver and Silver Properties, 73 Spring St NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/02/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Secure Data, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste 408 NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Mt Rd., Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 5/28/2008 123 LaSalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 John Kirtley, 339 Plant Ave., Tampa, FL
$1,000 5/28/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Springrich Limited Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/26/2008 Streetrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/26/2008 51 First Ave LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/26/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/26/2008 538-14 Realty, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/26/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/26/2008 Douglas Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 5/24/2008 The Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacremento, CA
$1,000 5/13/2008 Alan Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave NYC
$1,000 5/13/2008 123 LaSalle Assoc., 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/08/2008 Bradford Manufacturing, 73 Spring St. NYC

Tim Scott, House District 117 (won)
$1,000 5/30/2008 470 W. 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 51 First Ave LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY, Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd. 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 5/30/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Flr NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Douglas Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 5/21/2008 Alan J. Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave NYC
$1,000 5/14/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408
$1,000 5/14/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 The Stonecreek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA

(i)Curtis Brantley, House District 122 (won)(65%)
$1,000 5/28/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 405 49 Associates 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 4220 Broadway Inc. 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St., NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Howard Rich, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Bradford Mgmt. of NY Inc., 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Rich & Rich Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Rich Acquisitions LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 123 Lasalle, Inc., 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 26 Broadway NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/28/2008 The Stonecreek Group [Kevin Spillane] Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/28/2008 Paul Farago, P.O. Box 8907 Asheville, NC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway NYC
$1,000 6/23/2008 Yvonne Rich, 21111 West Rd. Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 6/19/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway NYC
$1,000 6/19/2008 Doug Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL

(i) Richard Chalk, House District 123 (won)
$1,000 5/27/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Fl. NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC

(i) Mike Fair, Senate District 6 (won)
$1,000 5/30/2008 Paul Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1,000 5/30/2008 Kevin Spillane, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd., Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/30/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 26 Broadway Floor 23rd Fl NYC
$1,000 5/30/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 160 W 97th St. NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 3/23/2008 Alan J Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave NYC

Dee Compton, Senate 10 (won)
$1000 6/20/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Rich & Rich Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Rich & Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Newrich, LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Dayrich, LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 51 First Ave. LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Secure Data LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Spooner LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Silver & Silver Properties LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Rich Acquisitions LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 507 NYC
$1000 6/11/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 406 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Springrich LP, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 Streetrich, LLC, 73 Spring St. Ste. 408 NYC
$1000 5/24/2008 West 14 & 18 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1000 6/26/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Alan J. Pomerantz, 73 Spring St., Rm. 507 NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 W. Rd. 1 Mountain Home, AR
$1000 6/20/2008 Joseph D. Stilwell, 26 Broadway, 23rd Flr. NYC
$1000 6/20/2008 Paul R. Farago P.O. Box 8907 Asheville, NC
$1000 6/20/2008 Paul C. Jost, 2640 Jockey's Neck Trl. Williamsburg, VA
$1000 6/20/2008 Kevin Spillane, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd 191 Sacremento, CA
$1000 6/20/2008 Anita Anderson, 1161 Rhode Island St., San Francisco, CA
$1000 5/24/2008 John Kirtley, 339 S. Plant Ave., Tampa, FL
$1000 5/24/2008 Douglas Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd. Miami Beach, FL

Lee Bright, Senate District 12 (won)
$1,000 6/23/2008 Paul Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1,000 6/19/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Secure Data LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Silver & Silver Properties LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Spooner LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Rich & Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Springrich Limited Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Streetrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Rich Acquisitions, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Rich & Rich Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/16/2008 Rosemeade Investors LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 28 Broadway NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 6/11/2008 Douglas Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 5/29/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 5/29/2008 Douglas Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 5/29/2008 Joseph Stilwell, 28 Broadway NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 John Kirtley, 339 S Plant Ave, Tampa, FL
$1,000 5/29/2008 Kevin Spillane, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd 191, Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/29/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Bradford Mgmt of NY, Inc., 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Spring, Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 West 14 & 18 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Stilrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 123 Lasalle Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Silver & Silver Properties LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Spooner LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Secure Data LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Rich & Rich Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Rich Acquisitions, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Streetrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Springrich Limited Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 Rich & Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 123 Lasalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC

Katrina Shealy, Senate District 23 (lost)(51%)
$1,000 6/12/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Spooner LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Springrich Limited Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Trucker 49 LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 Streetrich LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 StillRich LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/12/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 West 14 & 18 LLC, 73 Spring St., Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St., Room 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Bradford Mgmt, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Ashborough Investors, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 4220 Broadway Inc, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Rich & Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Rich Acquisitions LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Rich & Rich Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Rosemead Investors LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Secure Data LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Spinksville LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Silver & Silver Properties, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 123 LaSalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 123 LaSalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Spring Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 Silver & Silver Properties, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 Secure Data LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 Rich Acquisitions LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 Rich & Rich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 Rich & Rich Associates, 73 Spring St., Room 408 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 Dayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 Bayrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 51 First Avenue LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/08/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 6/08/2008 407 W. 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/08/2008 Streetrich LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/08/2008 Spooner LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 6/08/2008 Springrich Limited Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000 5/31/2008 4220 Broadway LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/31/2008 4220 Broadway Inc, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/31/2008 405 49 Associates, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/31/2008 332 E 11 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/31/2008 188 Claremont LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/31/2008 123 LaSalle Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/06/2008 123 LaSalle Associates, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/06/2008 Bradford Mgmt, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 William A. Wilson, 14024 Woodbury Woods Ct. Fairfax, VA
$1,000 6/11/2008 Douglas H. Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 6/11/2008 Joseph D. Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Flr. NYC
$1,000 6/11/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Road 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 6/09/2008 Mark W Dane, 1500 Lexington Ave., Apt 23B NYC
$1,000 6/09/2008 William A. Wilson, 14024 Woodbury Woods Ct., Fairfax, VA
$1,000 6/09/2008 Anita Anderson, 1161 Rhode Island St., San Fransico, CA
$1,000 6/09/2008 Paul R Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1,000 6/09/2008 Alan J. Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Ave. NYC
$1,000 6/08/2008 Joseph D. Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Flr NYC
$1,000 6/04/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Road 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 6/04/2008 Sarah Vanderveen, 301 Forest Ave., Laguna Beach, CA
$1,000 6/04/2008 David Vanderveen, 301 Forest Ave., Laguna Beach, CA
$1,000 5/31/2008 The Stone Creek Group (Kevin Spillane) Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/31/2008 Paul C Jost, 2640 Jockey's Neck Trl, Williamsburg, VA
$1,000 5/31/2008 Chandler Mgmt (Paul C. Jost) Newport News, VA
$1,000 5/31/2008 Judith T. Wilson, 10424 Woodbury Woods Ct., Fairfax, VA
$1,000 5/28/2008 John Kirtley, 339 S. Plant Ave. Tampa, FL
$1,000 5/28/2008 Kimberly Kirtley, 339 S. Plant Ave. Tampa, FL
$1,000 5/28/2008 Douglas H. Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000 5/28/2008 Carol S Pomerantz, 1185 Park Avenue, Apt 5C NYC
$1,000 5/15/2008 Eric S. Okeefe, 5367 Highway C, Spring Green, WI
$1,000 5/15/2008 E & L Corporation, PO Box 279, Spring Green, WI
$1,000 5/15/2008 Joe A. Pence, 424 Flinthill Place, Mountain Home, AR

(i)Greg Ryberg, Senate District 24 (won)
$1,000 5/28/2008 Kevin Spillane, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd 191, Sacramento, CA
$1,000 5/28/2008 Paul R Farago, PO Box 8907, Asheville, NC
$1,000 5/28/2008 Joseph D Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Floor, NYC
$1,000 5/27/2008 123 LaSalle Inc, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Rd 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000 5/23/2008 123 LaSalle Associates - A Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm. 507 NYC
$1,000 5/23/2008 Alan J Pomerantz, 767 Fifth Avenue NYC

Levone Graves, Senate District 30 (lost)
$1,000 5/29/2008 4220 Broadway Inc., 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 538-14 Realty LLC, 73 Spring St. NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 406-49 Associates LLC 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 5/29/2008 332 E-11 LLC, 73 Spring Street NYC
$1,000 4/29/2008 123 La Salle Associates, 73 Spring Street NYC

(i)Robert Ford, Senate District 42 (won)
$1,000 6/06/2008 Vanguard Admiral 470 W 166 LLC, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000
5/22/2008 123 Lasalle Associates - A Partnership, 73 Spring St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000
5/22/2008 Realty LLC, 73 Springs St. Rm 408 NYC
$1,000
5/22/2008 Newrich LLC, 73 Springs St. Rm. 408 NYC
$1,000
5/18/2008 Yvonne Rich, 2111 West Road 1, Mountain Home, AR
$1,000
5/15/2008 Douglas H. Levine, 2760 N. Bay Rd., Miami Beach, FL
$1,000
5/12/2008 Joseph D. Stilwell, 26 Broadway 23rd Floor NYC
$1,000
5/10/2008 The Stonecreek Group, 2443 Fair Oaks Blvd. Sacramento, CA

26 comments:

Anonymous said...

This should be front page news of every newspaper in this state. It is despicable that such arrogance is succeeding in buying our electoral process.
Where is the "sunshine" on these activities? If it weren't for bloggers such as B&P, we wouldn't know how blatant this is.
Where one stands on vouchers shouldn't keep one from seeing that it is simply wrong for an individual to be able to buy SC's political process. And please note that these $$$ don't even include SCRG's thousands that were poured into negative campaign mailings. Who knows where their money comes from? It's entirely possible that those $$$ come from Howard Rich, too, but we'll never know since they don't have to report their contributions.

Anonymous said...

How much $$$ does the NEA, SCEA, and George Soros pour into SC elections?

How much $$$ does the NEA, SCEA and George Soros give this blog?

Rod Shealy should be ashamed. I can't believe his associates could be purchased so cheaply to protect a bottom dwelling education system.

We suck sooooo let's done change a thing.

Anonymous said...

Gervais,

You're a Great American!

Keep up the great work, and take an extra rib or two the next time you have a chance. We still owe you a BBQ dinner with all the fixins.

Can you tell us how much voucher scam money is being funneled over to our ol'buddy sic(k) will folks?

We all know he's taking all he can get, but we wonder how much?

BIN News Editorial Staff

Boyd Brown said...

Ross:

Great work the entire way around. Hope all is going well.

Boyd Brown

Anonymous said...

Gervais,
Are there any similar statistics for the South Carolina Club for Growth? They use the same tactics - individual checks for the $1,000 maximum posted on the same day (in the same envelope, perhaps?) and primarily received during the black-out period. They also seem to be supporting the very same candidates as the SCRG crowd! Hmmmm! For example, in the District 81 House race, Mr. Singer received $21,000
(15 checks from the Spring Street address and 6 individual checks from Mr. Rich's friends). He also received $11,000 easily attributed to the SC Club for Growth crowd. Mr. Singer told the Aiken Standard that he plans to return all but $3,000 attributed to the Rich address. That means he still got $20,000 from these two groups and also benefitted from about 5 attack fliers and radio spots paid for by SCRG and/or SCCG. Unbelievable.

Anonymous said...

Bin News,
Will Folks works for those groups, sure, but he also works for Howard Rich directly, doing research for opinion/editorial pieces, among other things. A brief look at his tax documents could show you a thing or two if you have the means to do it.

Anonymous said...

How much money is in Sanfraud's personal slush fund----and those of his friends? Where did it come from?

When will the religious conservatives distance themselves from the libertarian hedonists (Willie Sicko, cokehead Ravenel, and friends)?

George Soros giving money in SC? LOL. NEA? Someone needs to read a book or two (do some research). The NEA has about as much influence in SC as Hugh Hefner has at the Southern Baptist Convention. Stop guzzling the Kool-Ade and get a grip on reality. Pre-college public education didn't really even begin in SC until 1977. Tremendous progress has been made in 30 years.

I challenge all nay-sayers and know-it-alls to teach middle school in one of the poorest districts in the state for a month. Then we'll talk.

Anonymous said...

"Tremendous progress has been made in 30 years.

I challenge all nay-sayers and know-it-alls to teach middle school in one of the poorest districts in the state for a month. Then we'll talk."

hmmmmm seems like you agree with the dismal state of our education system. Tremendous progress? Then why the challenge to teach in poor districts.

The fact is the system is broken and no amount of $$$ going to and through educrats is going to change the fact that students outside affluent counties and districts get shafted. Dick Riley's reforms and every package after . . . billions of dollars . . . down the tubes

Anonymous said...

laughable . . . honestly, it's clearly visible the NEA and SCEA funds this stuff.

If only Soro's groups (Dem Alliance,etc.) got this much attention.

If only someone would go after that crook McConnell and the millions he's fleeced from the state for his sub project. Who cares how Rich spends his cash . . nobody cares how McConnell spends SC taxpayer cash.

Anonymous said...

Gervais,

You know will folks is bloated with voucher scam money. If BIN News can find it, we're sure you can.

Are you looking? Do you care? Hmmm.

BIN News Editorial Staff

Anonymous said...

Will Folks is just a bit player for Howard Rich here... He does is "message" and his "research" and all that and Howie pays him a lot for doing the Rich/SCRG public relations on the FITSnews website. I don't think that's really a question...

Silence Dogood said...

Anon at 10:05, if the NEA is and George Soros are dumping big dollars into S.C. elections (presumabley for Democrats?) then put your money where your mouth is, give us a run down of the out of state money funding scam for these candidates and where all the money is coming from...I am wrapt with anticipation to see it. Check the filings and let us know. Tic-tock.

Cooter Head said...

I love how Scott Singer returned all but $3K because of some flawed logic about Ethics Law and a $3K limit. See, the problem is that Singer has to check a law book to determine his stand on ethics. He doesn't have an innate sense of right and wrong. The boy is a fraud and huckster of the highest order. Scott, for your educimation, if you were an ethical person you would have returned ALL of Howie Rich's money.

Silence Dogood said...

Anon from 10:05 PM, tick-toc goes the clock, let's hear about the $500,000 contribution effort to the legislature from the NEA and other "evil" groups that support public education, similar to this effort by Howard Rich (a sinlge individual mind you)?

Tick-toc. In all honesty I am really interested to hear.

Anonymous said...

I agree. Anon from 10:05 PM should put up or shut up!

Anonymous said...

I think anon 10:05's silence says it all.

Anonymous said...

SC public school test scores for the last 30 years say it all. Congrats on you and the teachers' union for keeping the status quo.

You all should be proud of your consistent poor performance. No wonder major manufacturers are shunning SC . . . you all are too dumb.

Any other entity would have changed a long time ago. All sites like this, funded by Educrat establishments, do is keep the fat cats in place and the people of SC stupid stupid stupid.

Unions have fought tough and nail to NOT disclose where they send money and who they fund. There is know way to ever know how much cash the NEA and SCEA sends this "front" blog . . . but from the content it's very evident who is writing the checks.

Quick > will someone from this site tell us how to improve education in SC? No, you can't use the "mo' money" angle because that has tried and failed for the last 30 years.

Milton Friedman is one of the brightest minds of the last 100 years. You guys are morons.

Daisy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Daisy said...

Quick > will someone from this site tell us how to improve education in SC?

Anon, have you signed on as a private free tutor for the poor children in SC, yet? Why not? If something needs to be done, how about YOU get off your judgmental, self-righteous ass and start doing what needs to be done? And if you don't want to do that, I guess you aren't much different than whoever you are criticizing.

PEOPLE TAKING RESPONSIBILITY ON A PERSONAL LEVEL is what will change things, education AND health care, etc... certainly, not common bribery.

Then why the challenge to teach in poor districts.

To see if you are a serious person and to determine whether you have a clue about what you are talking about. In short, to see if you are full of it or not, of course.

And as we see, indeed, you are.

Georgetown Democrat said...

Excellent coverage on a situation, if not fixed, will destroy public education and its accomplishments in the state of South Carolina.

Keep it up!

Anonymous said...

Daisy,

Well said. Thank you.

Anonymous said...

Daisy,

interesting point regarding personal responsibility . . . that's exactly what vouchers will help poor people do . . . pull their kids out of failing schools and send them somewhere else for a good education. Under the present system, they have to move into another district but can't move because they are too poor.

Instead of the Government telling them where their kids HAVE to go, vouchers will enable kids in failing schools to have a CHOICE to go elsewhere.

Outside of the larger metro areas, the education system in SC is shot, it's time for new ideas and to try something different ... the last 30 years provides all the evidence you need that "tweaks" and "mo' money" don't work.

Anonymous said...

Hooray, hooray! Vouchers are going to help the poor! Yes, give me my $3,500 voucher so my kid can go to school with the governor's children. Wait, you mean $3,500 won't get me into school with the governor's children? But you said I would have a choice.

Silence Dogood said...

Tick toc, tick toc, anon never did answer my question about all the NEA and George Soros funding for S.C. legislative candidates. None the less this witty diddy really make me laugh:

"There is know way to ever know how much cash the NEA and SCEA sends this "front" blog . . . but from the content it's very evident who is writing the checks. "

That is a FANTASTIC response. Howie Rich literally tries to buy the S.C. legislature via half a million dollars plus in direct donations to candidates campaigns...yet wait...the NEA or SCEA may (but not necessarily) though just may have a blog at its disposal. Well, looks like Howie Rich and the gang don't stand a chance because heavne knows it takes a lot more than $500,000 to run a blog.

I literally have tears streaming down my face. Maybe one day, if my wife and pinch our pennies, invest well, and win a lottery scratch off or two - we will be able to "write the checks" and afford our own blog. But unfortunately like the underfunded NEA and SCEA we will apparently not be able to afford a WHOLE blog and have to share at least half of our air time with S.C. bar-b-que or some other topic. Hey, we can't all be millionaires.

Former Sen. Phil Gramm (TX) said...

Silence, that is hillarious, but maybe if you didn't "whine" the economy would be better and you and Mrs. Dogood could afford a blog of your own sonner than you think. Either way, with all the blog foreclosures going on you could probably get one for $250,000 give/take. But it will still take you a while to build blog equity in a crumbling market.

Anonymous said...

Here is an update on the financial disclosure of Scott Singer's campaign based on the updated report posted this week. You will remember that Mr. Singer told the Aiken Standard that he planned to return "all but $3,000" of the Rich money. Well, Mr. Singer received $21,000 from Rich and his associates. He did return $12,000all from donors at the Spring Street address. He kept $3,000 from Spring Street and $6,000 from Rich associates. Then, in July, he received $5,000 more - $2,000 from the Spring Street address and $3,000 from individuals, Rich cronies all. Total take of Rich money - $14,000.